You are here

Joy Luck Club

6 posts / 0 new
Last post
Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture
Joy Luck Club

I chose this movie, because I have copies of this book in my classroom, and this novel is actually on the suggested reading in Appendix B on the Common Core Suggested texts for 9th and 10th grade English (my subject). So, I was interested to see the movie and what themes I would be able to use in the classroom. My favorite part of this seminar so far as been learning about the customs and traditions of other cultures, so I really enjoyed viewing this film and learning about the Chinese cultures, and seeing aspects from the seminar in the film. For instance, that confucian notion of respecting your elders was presented throughout the whole movie. My favorite scene, was the wedding scene when she first has to "pay respect to her elders." This was also presented in the dinner scene (I think Clay actually used this example in class) where her American boyfriend takes a huge helping on shrimp before the elders are served. It was a really enjoyable movie.

In terms of relating it to my classroom, I think that I would be able to read this and show parts of it in the classroom. The novel as well of the movie show examples of war, and traditions, which are very rich in Chinese history. So, I think I would be able to have students do further research about what they have read in the novel. Also, it might be fun to have students discuss their own family traditions and customs and "unspoken rules." I'm looking forward to being able to teach this compelling novel next year.

Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture
Message from gsharpe

I love this film, and it can be used to exemplify many aspects of Confucianism. In particular, the "three submissions". When I teach students about the three submissions, they automatically believe women had no rights and no voices. Joy Luck Club does a fantastic job of showing women who stay within the confines of traditional Chinese culture, but still retain a sense of self.
edited by gsharpe on 5/2/2013

Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture
Message from tlentz

I love this film so much, but I always skip a few scenes that are too painful to watch! aaxelson... I watched the Vice doc on China and it blew my mind.

Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture
Message from aaxelson

Yeah, I know what you mean about skipping scenes. The part where the mother drowns her own child, is painful. One of the mothers in the film leaves her twins behind during a time of war... does anyone know what war that is? And, yes, the Vice doc is crazy. Such a cultural difference!!!

Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture
Message from

this was a great movie. I also read the book. I believe it takes place during the World War I. The fourth wife who committed suicide by taking opium in the movie was based on her grandmother and the child who witnessed it was her mother. I have a couple of Amy Tan's other books too but I haven't got around to reading them.
edited by daniellein on 3/21/2014

Anonymous (not verified)
Anonymous's picture
Message from

Great movie always.It was always used to exemplify many aspects of Confucianism during the world war.Students can see this movie or read the novel and unreveal their own customs and "unspoken rules.