You are here

Wasserstrom, China's Brave New World - And Other Tales For Global Times, 2007

Tom Plate reviews this book for AsiaMedia, June 2007
January 1, 2007
Print

How to understand China

By Tom Plate

This review was originally published by AsiaMedia on June 13, 2007. Republished by permission

Los Angeles --- America needs more people like Professor Jeffrey Wasserstrom, a heretofore humble academic here on the West Coast. Let me explain.

Understanding China is going to remain irritatingly difficult. It's an obviously important but intensely problematic place, with a possibly fabulous or possibly tragic future. We maybe have a better shot figuring out the future of India -- or even Mars -- than China.

If we leave the job of thinking about China to our general mass news media, we will wind up with mainly superficial portraits of the parts of China most visible to the eye and to the camera, while losing all sight and sense of that part of China that is clandestine -- or at least well beneath the surface.

The downside of a gross misunderstanding looms ever more significant almost every time we look over our shoulder -- and see China coming on strong, economically as well as militarily.

The latest trade figures themselves are cause to lose one's breath. Get this: The mainland's trade surplus for May increased by 73 percent compared to a year ago. The May surplus alone with the U.S. was $ 22.45 billion -- that's billions, not millions!

What this means is several-fold.

For starters, China's trade surplus will sour the sweetness and lightness of Sino-U.S. bilateral relations, especially with the U.S. presidential election coming. It's hard to see many candidates laying off of China in a statesmanlike way when it's so large a target and indeed so invitingly clumsy a punching bag.

There are always many votes to be gained from bashing them --- them being the Chinese this time around (the last time around was in the late eighties and early nineties, when the Japanese, sporting huge economic successes, were in effect blamed by some Americans for U.S. economic deficiencies.)

And so, serious people on both sides of the Pacific Pond will want to avoid being taken in by the utterly transparent self-serving swirl of U.S. domestic politics. But they will also want to know the true score: They will be no more inclined to trust the word of Beijing than of Washington.

To this end, we will need to depend more and more on heavyweights who can bring us illumination about China without blinding us with sensationalist stereotypes or mind-numbing qualifications.

Exhibit A would be to have available for reporting duty more observers like Wasserstrom, history professor from the University of California, Irvine. His publisher (Indiana University Press) is offering us his new book, titled China's Brave New World -- And Other Tales For Global Times.

It is rather effortlessly brilliant, as it reads almost as breezily as a scantily clad advice column in a glossy woman's magazine. It penetrates with a lightly knowing eye and ear into the interior mind, heart and soul of giant China and the innumerable Chinese.

The good professor's main approach to getting us deeper into China's DNA is to not act like the typical professor. That is -- forget the fudging footnotes and the dodgy theories. Instead, dip into the easy writing and clear expression, the common-touch of forcing you to come with him into the coffee shop to chat with students or stick with him as your guide as he takes you down China's event-filled memory lanes.

In his collections of essays, Wasserstrom helps us understand more about China in a way that inoffensively suggests how little we know -- and by implication how little the professor knows despite in fact knowing so much -- relatively speaking.

"I ask," he writes, "does it mean the same thing when a Starbucks or a bowling alley opens in Beijing as opposed to Boise, the Canton of China as opposed to the Canton in Ohio?" His emphatic answer, you quickly find out, is that it dramatically does not -- and you find out exactly why.

Although he admits to exceptions (as do I), hard-core Western academic "experts" declaiming on China generally leave him cold. And although he agrees that there are some excellent American foreign correspondents working on the mainland (as do I), he has little love for their editors back in the U.S. and or in Europe, who resist originality and force their copy into preconceived pigeonholes -- with the size of the pigeons getting smaller with every corporate tightening of the news hole.

China's Brave New World is full of insights over a broad China canvas. "Too often," Wasserstrom writes, "Americans curious about China feel they have only two options: accept the overly simplistic answers to big questions provided by a sound bite-driven mass media, or look for alternatives in stuffy academic works that can be off-putting due to the style in which they are written. I want to offer a third option: a playful look at serious issues..."

As I say, the world needs more Jeffrey Wasserstroms to come forward, urgently.

********************************************************************

Tom Plate is a UCLA professor of communication and policy studies. His syndicated Pacific Perspectives column appears regularly in the Seattle Times, Providence Journal, Japan Times, The Korea Times, South China Morning Post, the Straits Times and other newspapers. Prof. Plate founded the Asia Pacific Media Network and is now the director of the UCLA Media Center.

Print